New York Pizza Express

Discover authentic NY-style pizza at New York Pizza Express in Stallings, NC. Enjoy cheesy, chewy crusts, flavorful stromboli, meatball subs, wings, and more. Call +1 704-821-2020 today!

Welcome to New York Pizza Express

Signature Dining Experience

New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express

Nestled in the heart of Stallings, North Carolina, New York Pizza Express delivers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza. From its inviting atmosphere to its mouthwatering menu, this pizza restaurant is a community favorite. Regulars rave about the chewy crust, generous toppings, and the signature homemade ranch dressing that takes each bite to the next level. Whether you're craving a classic cheese slice or the indulgent meat lovers pizza, you'll find something that satisfies your pizza desires here. The restaurant offers a relaxed dining experience, perfect for families and friends gathering over delicious food. Those visiting for the first time will soon understand why this spot becomes an instant favorite.

Location & Contact

Address

4520 Potter Rd, Stallings, NC 28104, United States

Phone

+1 704-821-2020

Social Media

About

New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express
New York Pizza Express

New York Pizza Express has become a cherished culinary staple among Stallings residents. Opened with the mission of bringing the classic flavors of New York to North Carolina, the restaurant has gained a loyal customer base since its inception. The establishment takes pride in using high-quality ingredients, ensuring that every dish reflects a commitment to excellence. Plus, the kitchen crafts everything from scratch, resulting in tasty crusts, savory sauces, and fresh toppings across the board.

Every Tuesday through Sunday, patrons flood in to enjoy flavorful slices, with Fridays being the most bustling day at 6 PM. The blend of casual dining and exceptional service makes it a go-to spot for pizza lovers, families, and anyone looking to indulge in hearty Italian-American cuisine.

The wide variety on the menu ensures that every visit offers something new, yet familiar favorites keep customers returning. Unique offerings like homemade ranch dressing elevate the experience, while diners can enjoy classic comforts such as spaghetti with meatballs or baked ziti. New York Pizza Express contributes to the local culture, becoming a hub where families celebrate, friends bond, and community events unfold. With special dinner offerings rotating weekly, the restaurant keeps the menu fresh and exciting, immersing visitors in a fun and flavorsome culinary journey.

Completion of your meal would be unthinkable without a sweet decadence to cap off the experience. The dessert selection includes irresistible cheesecakes and cannolis, wrapping up the evening on a delightfully sweet note.

Work Hours

  • Sunday1-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

New York Pizza Express boasts an extensive menu with over 80 items, ensuring there's something for everyone. Crack open a menu filled with delightful pizzas, including the famous white pizza and cheesy strombolis. Appetizers like mozzarella sticks and chicken tenders kick off your meal right. Don't forget to try the hearty meatball sub, loaded with juicy meatballs and melted cheese. The restaurant offers lunch specials that provide customary fare at unbeatable prices, perfect for a quick bite during the workday. With takeout options available, it's easy to enjoy a slice at home, too. During busy times, like Friday evenings when it hits full capacity, the staff remains efficient, ensuring you receive great service even amidst the rush.

New York Pizza Express

The exterior of New York Pizza Express radiates a warm and welcoming vibe. Bright signage and warm colors invite both locals and visitors to step inside. The inside charm continues, with cozy booths and oversized tables perfect for gatherings. The buzz of the kitchen and the aroma of baking pizza create an inviting atmosphere where good times come naturally. During warmer months, outdoor seating becomes popular, transforming a pizza night into a charming al fresco dining experience. Families often choose this spot for its friendly environment, making every visit feel like a casual meal with friends.

Customer Reviews

This is the best pizza I've had since moving to CLT by far. Prices are good. Won't be going anywhere else!

N
Nathan S.

Tried for the first time today and this is my new favorite pizza place around. Reminds me of when I lived up north which is rare around here. Great pizza, reasonable prices, and the salad was great too. Will be my new go-to.

J
Jake C.

The place looks a little run down and could use some updates, but don't let that fool you -- the pizza is absolutely amazing! The crust is perfectly cooked, the sauce has great flavor, and the toppings taste fresh. You can tell they really know how to make a good pizza. It might not look fancy from the outside, but the food more than makes up for it. Definitely worth a visit if you're after great pizza and don't mind a spot that's a little rough around the edges.

R
Rome O.

I've been searching for pizza baked like the pizza I grew up eating in Western NY my entire adult life. Then I found NY Pizza Express and it is absolutely the finest pizza I have had in decades of living in NC. They serve the best Italian food in the Carolinas hands down! Fantastic , and atmosphere.

J
Jeffrey B.

Excellent Pizza. Call in and pick it up. Don't miss out on this pizza that is cooked to perfection and not greasy. Plenty of toppings for the pizzas including green olives. Give New York Pizza Express a try for your next pizza order.

A
American E.

Honestly the best pizza around. Crunchy crust, non-greasy (idk how they manage that but it's amazing), quick, and delicious. The buffalo chicken is our favorite and by far the best buffalo chicken pizza we've had! Don't judge a book by its cover, this place is awesome.

C
Chessie D.